“Do not take videos at the checkpoints, as it is strictly prohibited,” warns the bus driver, as our bus convoy passes by the checkpoints of Azerbaijani armed forces and Russian peacekeepers. Here, at the intersection of two different roads – one leading to Shusha, the other to Khankendi, the invisible scars of the past war seem evident. The former was liberated by Azerbaijani forces during the Second Karabakh War of 2020, the latter is being temporarily controlled by the Russian peacekeeping mission until 2025 per the trilateral agreement signed by the leaders of Azerbaijan, Russia, and Armenia concluding the combat operations in Karabakh region of Azerbaijan.
Though the roads have been completely renovated, however, the destruction in and around the city of Shusha keeps reminding us of the tragic three decades, which left the crown city of Karabakh under the occupation of Armenia-backed Karabakh separatists. Once entering the city through the “Road of Victory,” one may feel like in a huge construction site, where trucks loaded with construction supplies stroll around the city and billboards about the projected urban development plans stand by the half-ruined mansions once inhabited by Shusha’s local nobility.
The arterial street of Shusha leads to the Yukhari Govhar Agha Mosque, the city’s main Islamic structure and of the beautiful examples of medieval Azerbaijani architecture, built in the 18th century, and located only several blocks from the Armenian Cathedral of Ghazanchetsots, both being renovated by the Azerbaijani government. For many, this is a sign of future peace and trust between two communities. But what does Azerbaijan propose for the ethnic Armenians living in Karabakh?
Ethnic Armenians comprise around 1.3% of Azerbaijan’s population, which makes them the third largest ethnic minority group in the country. Over the years of illegal occupation of Azerbaijani territories by Armenia, the vast majority of ethnic Armenians remained in Karabakh, with some groups living in Baku and Sumgayit. The reconciliation process initiated by Azerbaijan, primarily by President Ilham Aliyev, aims to restore mutual trust between communities and integrate ethnic Armenians into Azerbaijani society. The integration strategy has seen huge support from the international community and prominent western political analysts and diplomats.
In an interview with Baku-based Trend News Agency, Irina Tsukerman, a New York-based human rights, and national security expert stated that ethnic Armenians in Karabakh need to contribute in equal measure to the development of Azerbaijan. “The only real way to protect their rights is for them to have Azerbaijani citizenship and the same rights under the law. And the only way for them to integrate and benefit from what Azerbaijan has to offer is to act like other citizens and view the national idea of a state as an idea greater than purely ethnic lines and accept the responsibility that helps contribute to a stronger and better society,” the expert added.
The Constitution of the
Republic of Azerbaijan ensures equality for everyone, including representatives
of national minorities before the law and equality of rights and freedoms of an
individual irrespective of his or her race, ethnicity, religion, and language.
A solid example of the state-level protection of national minorities can be the
consideration of the rights of ethnic minority groups at institutional, as well
as NGO levels. Since 2013, the Special Commission under the Ministry of Justice
operates on the conditional release of sentenced persons and the replacement of
the unserved part of the sentence with a milder form of penalty. NGOs, where
representatives of national minorities are represented together with other
organizations are involved in its activities.
At a local level, ethnic
minority groups, such as Lezgis, Talysh people, Georgians, Mountain Jews, as
well as Russians and Tats enjoy the freedom of cultural preservation, enabling
them to preserve and revive their culture, traditions, and customs in community
centers, religious organizations, and even in their theatres. In point of fact,
Russian and Lezgi theatres based in Baku and Gusar, respectively, have been the
cultural centers of both communities for decades. Red Village or Qırmızı Qəsəbə
is among many examples of unique coexistence in Azerbaijan, where Jews and
Muslims not only live side by side but also share joy and sorrow altogether. As
a music-loving society, for many Azerbaijanis regardless of their ethnicity,
the Talysh folk group “Nənələr” (“Grandmothers”) is a favorite choice when it
comes to public concerts that are regularly attended by thousands.
Taking into account the aforementioned facts, it should be noted that the reconciliation and peace agenda envisages the preservation of the cultural and religious rights of ethnic Armenians, ensuring a smooth integration into Azerbaijani society, where they will be able to enjoy constitutional rights like all other citizens of Azerbaijan. Development of culture and free practice of religion are among some fundamental rights promised by the Azerbaijani government and backed by the Constitution.
Woefully, the public opinion among ethnic Armenians living in Khankendi, and its neighboring districts have been influenced by ideologists whose main goal has been the destabilization of the region, followed by the spread of ethnic hatred among the two communities. The destructive intentions against the possible peace agenda can still be seen in the messages of some foreign politicians, who irresponsibly support the holdouts of separatists in Karabakh, as well as Armenian officials, who intentionally create an image of “impossible coexistence” between the two communities.
As both Azerbaijan and Armenia are about
to mark the second anniversary of the trilateral agreement concluding the
Second Karabakh War, hopes for peace remain high despite the recent
provocations along the Armenia-Azerbaijan state border and baseless arguments
given by Armenian officials. For some, the 10-kilometer distance between Shusha
and Khankendi soon will no longer be a road of separation and hatred, as both
Azerbaijani cities will enjoy the free movement and coexistence, as it used to
be some 35 years ago.
Suliddin Baghirov
Journalist
Ph.D. candidate in Political
and Administrative Sciences,
University of Wroclaw, Poland
Member of Azerbaijan Diaspora
Youth platform
